Department of Justice is now the Department of Communities and Justice.  Find out more >

cjb248

Author Evarn J. Ooi and Sara Rahman
Published April 2022
Report Type Crime and Justice Bulletin No. CJB248
Subject Aboriginal / Indigenous Australians; Evaluation reports; Sentencing; Recidivism / Re-offending
Keywords Evaluation, Aboriginal Australians, Young people, Sentencing, Recidivism/Re-offending

Summary

Background

The Youth Koori Court (YKC) is an alternative case management process for Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander young people charged with a criminal offence(s). It has been available to eligible offenders appearing in Parramatta Children’s Court (CC) since February 2015 and Surry Hills CC since February 2019.
The YKC differs from the standard court process in several ways:
1. Sentencing is deferred for up to 12 months after the young person has indicated that they are willing to plead guilty or had the offence proven after hearing;
2. An Action and Support plan is developed and implemented to address the young person’s underlying risk factors for offending, which is supported by a caseworker and nominated Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Elders or Respected Persons, and;
3. Participation in the Youth Koori Court process is taken into account by the court when sentencing the young person for their index offence.
As of January 2021, 151 Aboriginal young people had been referred to the YKC. We examined the sentencing and re-offending outcomes for these young people, compared to 2,883 young people who met the observable eligibility criteria but had their matter finalised in NSW CCs where YKC was not available. We did this in two ways:
1. Using a linear probability regression model to adjust for differences between the groups on a range of covariates including demographics, index appearance details, and criminal history; and
2. Using a difference-in-differences model to estimate the change in outcomes before and after the establishment of the YKC at Parramatta CC.

Key findings

Our main estimates identify that YKC participants were:
• 5.9 percentage points less likely to be sentenced to a Juvenile Control Order (JCO);
• 7.6 percentage points less likely to be sentenced to a JCO at re-conviction within 12 months of index court finalisation (if they were not sentenced to a JCO at index finalisation).
These results were corroborated by the DiD estimate, which indicated an 8.1 percentage point reduction in the likelihood of being sentenced to a JCO. These reductions in imprisonment likelihood are statistically significant and remain even after including a wide range of control variables in the regression specification.
 Estimated reductions in the likelihood of a Juvenile Control Order (JCO)
Estimated reductions in the likelihood of a Juvenile Control Order (JCO)

Conclusion

The findings suggest an association between participation in the YKC and reduced risk of imprisonment, without any adverse impact on re-offending rates. However, the research design was unable to entirely rule out selection effects.